Fuhler, Farris, and Nelson (2006) emphasize the importance of teacher modeling because it's one of the most effective ways to increase students' higher level thinking and comprehension skills. I didn't necessarily model during this mini-lesson because there wasn't that much time, but I did model with a bag of my own during y fieldwork experience when we used artifact bags and I saw how much it helped the students. My powerpoint goes through the step by step process of how the students were supposed to go through the bag, so I had my peers do each step as I went through the slides. Even though I didn't model with another bag, I slowly went through all of the steps that I expected them to follow. Fuhler et al. (2006) also mention the importance of displaying the steps that you want the children to follow, which is what I did, but because I did my lesson in a small group, I went through one step at a time, instead of putting up a list. They wrapped some of their artifacts, which was something that I found interesting and I saw some classmates do, so I would definitely like to do that the next time that I use artifact bags. This is a great website to use when finding artifacts, which I will use in the future. I found this website on eclass and it gives you ways to find primary sources; students would love to see primary sources because it makes everything seem more realistic. I also found this source from eclass to be helpful because it gives you ideas of how to go about finding and/or using primary resources for each grade.
I absolutely love the concept of using artifact bags within the classroom because it hits all 5 of the elements of powerful social studies teaching: integrative, active, value-based, meaningful, and challenging. It's such an interesting and engaging way to reinforce a topic that you've already taught or maybe even to introduce a new topic. It's integrative because it can incorporate different core subjects and skills since the students have to really think about each object and the connection between them. Artifact bags are active because the students get to move around and physically touch the items, then discuss their thoughts about each one with their classmates. They're value-based in the sense that it shows you other cultures or parts of history and demonstrates that even though something may not be valuable to you, it can be valuable to someone else, so they have to be careful and respectful when touching the artifacts. Artifact bags should be challenging for the students; it should require them to genuinely think about their conclusion, not guess it right away. By incorporating all of these elements, the activity also becomes meaningful to the students. When an activity is engaging, hands-on, and just fun overall, then the students are much more likely to remember it because you've created a meaningful/memorable experience for them. This lesson could be adapted to work for any grade level, especially if you use the tips from the last source I provided because it really breaks down the different ways that you should implement primary sources and artifact bags throughout the different grade levels.
Here is the link to my PowerPoint I used to show my classmates my artifact bag!
